Showing posts with label Frank C. Stanley. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Frank C. Stanley. Show all posts

Monday, November 26, 2018

Regarding Mr. Banta and slow speeds

Frank P. Banta's death date is approaching, which is always a depressing time for me. I can barely express the words for how wonderful Banta was as a pianist, and how innocent and introverted the recording stars described him to be. The amount of praise Banta received from his studio fellows is quite outstanding. There are so few of those studio pianists mentioned in any context, but the only one that seemed immortal through recollection was Banta. 
That sweet smile is always heartwarming. 
Recently while digging around in period sources on the recording business, I finally found a better version of that Edison studio picture that was used in Edison catalogs years after Banta died:
Where do I begin with him? 
The praises that Dan W. Quinn spoke of Banta are quite an interesting read. Quinn praised Banta so highly for his unequalled ability to play anything by ear, and that Quinn would rather have Banta play at all his gigs and recording sessions. Quinn enjoyed Mr. Banta's company so much in fact, that he named his youngest child after Banta. According to the Quinn family, Dan passed down many stories that included Banta's presence and name. Clearly Quinn had quite a high respect for his pianist Mr. Banta. Compare that to the non-existent accounts of his time working with Fred Hylands at Columbia. Despite those not being written down, we know they happened. 
With Banta, it wasn't just Quinn who sung out his praises, it was also all the others at Edison, in more subtle ways however. Frank Stanley took the "Frank" in his studio name from that Mr. Banta. From written ledgers that survive from Edison, we know that Stanley worked very often with Banta. In fact, some of the most beautiful records Banta was on were recorded with Stanley, at least as far as I've heard. It's hard to beat these two gems:


That second one is particularly gorgeous, for a different reason then the first one.
 One thing that's very curious about Banta, in considering the other studio pianists, is the amount of his music that was recorded over time. It can be argued that he in fact wrote the most popular song of the brown wax era, and that's "the Laughing song". Of course he was not the origin of the song, that was George W. Johnson, but Banta deserves the credit for writing the song down on paper, and helping promote it to phonographers all over. Of course Banta remained modest about the overwhelming success with "the Laughing Song", as he remained respectful to Johnson's ownership of the tune. His name may have been on it, but he kept all the success in the studios solely, with the satisfaction of making Fred Hylands read his arrangement, and eventually butcher it for an old Cincinnati jig. Hylands may have had the publishing firm with Len Spencer, but Banta had the keys to the most popular and profitable song of the brown wax era. Other than "the laughing song", Banta's other pieces remained in the standard studio repertoire until as late as 1906. His earliest songs in the mid-1890's(after "the laughing song"), were likely recorded by Quinn and other popular singers of the mid-90's. His 1897 piece "The Chaser" was taken and kept for almost a decade by Fred Hager, as he recorded it with his orchestra in 1905. 
I have that very record to share here:
Even with all the very typical aspects to this march, I can still hear the characteristics that make it a Banta piece. Over the years I've studied his playing, it seems to have been more eccentric and self-taught than someone even as folksy as Hylands. Hylands had a distinct regional style, but Banta had his own mix of everything to create his style. Oddly enough, I would say that Banta's style was more closely related to Arthur Pryor's style than to Hylands'. There are a few reasons that I say that, the first being that the two were obviously close friends, recording two famous(or infamous rather) piano solos on the same day at Victor in 1900. 
You can view the ledgers here:
There they are, the pair of pianists at Victor in 1900. 
That's quite a pair! Not often would we associate a prominent figure as Arthur Pryor with such lost figures as the earliest studio pianists. I would guess that the reason the two were so well acquainted would stem back to their days at Berliner. Banta was working for Berliner as early as 1897, as was Pryor, and the few solos that Pryor made for them in that year almost certainly have Banta's accompaniment. Such as this one here: 
It seems perfectly in line to see those two rag-timers enjoying each other's company. 
Of course now that I have become well founded in the idea that all these band men knew each other, it seems almost certain they were constantly sharing each other's arrangements. Imagine it, Arthur Pryor, Hager, and Banta going out for a drink after the studio day, going to gossip about all the recording banter from the day.

So...another piece of Banta's that was recorded many years after it was written was his "Ragged William". As late as 1905 that piece was recorded by studio orchestras, in that year, the Regimental Band of the Republic revived the old Banta piece on the American label. 
Of course, this piece was recorded many times in 1899-1901 by Banta's own orchestra, the Metropolitan and Peerless orchestras. This oddity of a rag was rather popular with the studio groups, as I'm sure one of Hager's Zon-O-Phone ensembles recorded the piece in 1900 or 1901. I searched around for other versions of the piece and it seems that the tune was listed in the Leeds catalog around 1900. But of course it doesn't really come as a surprise that studio pianists' piece were recorded, as they had the best chances of getting anything they wrote recorded than anyone else. Banta's were just a bit more interesting and attractive to more than his own orchestra, compare that to Hylands' "The Darkey Volunteer".
 Banta's 1901 piece "Halimar" was also recorded. This particular piece had been a source of great interest for me, since I had wondered about it for so many years, with that oriental rondo subtitle to tantalize me, until I finally got a curious recording of it. 
By Hager's orchestra. 
The moment I saw that on Ebay I knew I had to snag it. Turns out this piece did not disappoint, it was definitely worth all the anticipation. Anyhow, you can hear my mediocre transfer here:
It's quite an interesting piece. So far, this piece presents all of Banta's self-taught eccentricities in composing and piano style. But of course the added bonus with this record is that it's my very favorite group playing it! To add some humor in this, I drew a cartoon with Pryor making a kind comment to Banta regarding this very record, with Hager himself well involved in dancing to the tune:
It's fun to imagine those three having so much fun together. 
It's clear that all those studio boys respected Banta to highly, and for good reason. He naturally had abilities that surpassed that of such musicians as Pryor and Hager. He must have also had a very rousing sense of humor, as well as an attractive demeanor, as he was quoted in 1892 saying thus:

"Oh that doesn't matter...just hum it over once and I'll catch it."

The only other early recording star who was documented of having that freakish ability was Silas Leachman. That must be why Leachman and Banta's records sounded so damn good. Also, i have come to believe that Banta was on some of the best of Leachman's Victors, such as these two:


I firmly believe that Leachman's hottest Victors are so hot because of Banta's accompaniment.  A long while ago I did a post regarding the frustration of Leachman's Victors in terms of piano accompaniment, but now I can pretty surely say that Hylands never accompanied Leachman on Victor, and with those records it's either Banta or Chris Booth. The more wild and ragged of Leachman's Victors likely have the Banta accompaniment. Now that I have become very used to hearing Banta's style on records, I have a very solid sense of what he tended to play overall, little eccentricities and characteristics. The most curious aspects to his playing that really don't make the most sense to me, in thinking of his musical region of origin, are the drone note and the rollicking/walking bass(you can hear a great example on this Leachman Victor here). Banta basically had all the aspects to his style of a rural pianist from way out west in Kansas, extra beats and measures included, but he was from New York. 
Where did he pick these up?
I have wondered that often when I hear records like this with Banta's accompaniment:
Clearly Banta had heard some things that he wasn't supposed to(as a respectable pianist). Isn't that how all these rough pianists got better? Indeed so. He had an ear that could pick up anything, so who knows where he would have gotten the ideas going through his mind at that moment on that record above. A similar record you can hear below:

In case you are wondering why that recording of "The Weddin O'er the Hill" is so significant, listen to this piece of serious folk rag-time, it's quite similar:
Both of these pieces by the famous Missouri wonder Blind Boone sound remarkably similar to some of the things I've heard Banta play on many records. Just one example, that bass note pattern at 1:23-1:24 is actually in his "Halimar". There are plenty more things that you can listen to on your own to pick out. Keep in mind that Boone didn't put together this piece of reminiscence(remembering music of the 1870's or so) until 1912. 
Anyway...


I will wear all black this Friday in honor of the sweet and gentle soul that was Frank P. Banta. His tragic life will remain immortal thanks to those who spoke of him so highly. 
We still hear you Mr. Banta. 






Well then!
In the last two days, I have been playing around with listening to some of my brown waxes, and others that are scattered online. A long while ago I did a post regarding the slow speed effect, of which I am still a very fond supporter. Awhile ago I acquired a very curious 1898 Columbia brown wax cylinder. My first brown wax cylinder was George P. Watson singing "Emmett's Lullaby" from 1898, but it is most certainly the most unusual take I've ever heard of it, but not for reasons these odd takes typically are. This particular take has a playing speed of just under 100 rpm. 
What?
Yes! You hear me right! Under 100 rpm. The oddly slow speed of this record creates some frustrating issues when playing it, of course. The grooves are very shallow, the speed fluctuates quite a lot, and the recording itself is rather quiet. It's worth the frustration because this record is definitely exceptional, the sound quality is very nice and clear, with loud and bass heavy piano accompaniment(by Hylands!). So here's where the slow speed idea comes into play, this record was made at a very slow speed, and I am fairly certain that this odd speed is correct for this particular record. Any slower it sounded unnatural, and any faster it sounded quick and low quality. 

So here's the thing about this...I have come to believe(after many discussions with collectors) that records from this era are supposed to sound slow to our modern ears, but these records can only sound as beautiful and clear as they truly were a bit slower than we'd usually think to play them. I believe in the quality of records from this time being great, I am a firm believer in the superiority of brown wax(as did Russell Hunting), and that acoustic recordings sounded better than most people would expect. An oddly good example of this contrast of too fast can be heard on this 1891 Issler accompaniment record:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-wI7RWfcb8
The speed fluctuates so much on this record that we can actually hear the difference between too fast and just right speed. When the record is slower(at the right speed) in the key of F, it sounds much fuller and well recorded, but when it speeds up, it sounds very low quality and the piano sounds distant. 
It's quite interesting how this turns out. If you listen to the record closely, you can tell that the record itself is already transferred very slow. 
So most scholarly record collectors know that these records are to be played much slower than 78, but often the speed of cylinders are all over the place. Just consider what I said about that Watson brown wax.

So with that in mind, I played my two William Tuson brown waxes slow. How they sounded so much better. The two Tuson clarinet solos I have are "Old Black Joe" and "Southern Plantation Echoes". Tuson's solo of "old Black Joe" sounded beautiful in A flat, it sounded slow and pretty at the straight section, and rather jumpy and folksy at the variations section. The piano accompaniment came through very well when I played it slow, every note came through, and I could even go to the piano and figure out the exact inversions of chords Hylands was playing. 
If you've got some records at home you're curious about, do try playing them a bit slower than you'd think to, it'll create quite a difference in quality!
Anyhow, I don't need to go on about this slow speed matter, it pretty much explains itself. 



Before I close out, I'd like to share one of my favorite Leachman and Banta records, to further honor Mr. Banta for this Friday:
https://adp.library.ucsb.edu/index.php/matrix/detail/100002499/Pre-matrix_B-3356-Mr._Johnson_dont_get_gay







Hope you are all having a good holiday season so far! 







Tuesday, June 26, 2018

Battling Banjoists and their accompanist

Banjoists Ruby Brooks(1861-1906) was on the same level of banjo skill as Vess Ossman, but in some ways, Brooks presented a banjo style that was eccentric and primitive in ways that others weren't. 
Brooks made enough records for record scholars to get hints as to what the more folksy banjo styles sounded like in the early years of the rag-time era. Keep in mind that Charles Asbury's style is as folksy as it gets, and the best it gets, as he was a black man born in Florida at the end of slavery days and learned to play the banjo from the best black performers of the later minstrel era. There is no comparison between the white recorded banjoists and black banjoists of the time, as the authenticity and dynamics of Asbury wins out the recorded white banjoists. 
Ossman and Brooks were equivalent adversaries, doing exactly the same repertoire at the same time, and playing at the same places. One familiar accompanist tied them together, despite their powerful senses of pride. In 1893, in a Lyceum Catalog, there lies this advertisement:
Banta! 
There he is with Master Ossman. It's very likely that Ossman shoved Banta into the recording studio, and got him that regular job there for the next ten years of his life. Ossman and Banta were a package it seems, at least for a few years, by 1896 splitting up as an official duo to allow more studio time for Banta. But luckily for Banta, we know Ossman was notoriously difficult, so splitting with old Vess must have been good for Banta's soul. What has this to do with Ruby Brooks? Well, it turns out than Banta showed an interest in Brooks toward the end of the 1890's. With Ossman being chained to Columbia's contract for a little while in 1898 and early 1899, this allowed for Edison to take in the other famous "banjo king" Ruby Brooks. That's exactly what they did, and the end result from that is a handful of outstanding records that surpass many of Ossman's records with Banta from a few years before. Brooks brought a style to recording that was very unlike Ossman's. It was much smoother in terms of syncopation, and even though it was sometimes out of whack and stumped Banta, it's charming in a way that Ossman's style wasn't always. Ossman's style perfectly exhibits his control-freak nature, as he was always in tune, and the rhythm was precise down to the  quickest 32nd notes. Ossman when he was interviewed often stressed how important it was for the banjo to be in tune and for the rhythm played to be precise throughout. This is why we don't get any extra or dropped measures in Ossman's playing. 
Unlike Ossman, with Brooks we get a very interesting mix of folk aspects that Ossman cast aside in the logic of his playing. 
Here's an outstanding example of Brooks' playing:
http://cylinders.library.ucsb.edu/search.php?queryType=@attr+1=1020&num=1&start=1&query=cylinder14584
Now keep in mind that the accompanist here is Banta.  Really listen to how ragged and smooth those last two strains are! Just a few years before Banta was working only with Ossman outside of the studio. Now, by 1899-1900 Banta had built a relationship with Brooks that provided some curious benefits. Brooks and his long-time partner Harry Denton had set up a publishing firm in the mid-1890's, and by the end of the decade had proved a popular publisher for recording stars and popular performers. With Brooks officially in the recording business, it made more sense to publish some fellow studio stars' work. That's just what he did. In 1899-1902, Brooks and Denton published some of Banta's most popular music, including Banta's "Ragged William"
(from Bill Edwards' website)
Brooks and Denton also published Banta's  later work "Halimar", which is an oriental dance(don't have a decent picture of the cover though...). With Brooks' founded interest in Banta, it's likely that Brooks published the last bunch of Banta's work. Banta was only doing his job by accompanying Brooks at Edison, but it's clear that Brooks took a greater interest in the former Ossman accompanist. Their records prove a partnership that fits together better than ever. Banta's syncopation was just as smooth and graceful as Brooks', as can well be heard in the recording of "Hunky Dory Cake-Walk" above. This particular record is the best of the best in terms of Brooks' records in fact. The others that provide good examples are nice, but can't compare to the "Hunky Dory" take. 
Here's another good one from around the same time:
https://archive.org/details/RubyBrooks
It's an awful shame the piano accompaniment is so obscured by the crappy transfer. That's okay though, we get to hear Brooks' unequalled and unique skill loud and clear. What makes Brooks so different from Ossman is that Brooks had no formal training to play the banjo. Like singer Frank C. Stanley, Brooks learned how to play the banjo completely on his own and from hearing the old black banjoists around him. This is what makes Brooks style more authentic and attractive on records. His entirely itinerant style comes through on each of his records, and makes them all the more unique. This is what tied together Banta and Brooks, and what makes their records just that extra amount of special that Ossman's just aren't. Banta, as far as we know, was self-taught at the root of his style, and with perfect pitch that would provide reason for little musical training beyond basic theory studies. 
Banta, even though he had experience with Ossman and provided for some very sleek examples of banjo rag-time(accompanying Ossman), added something special to records he made with Brooks. 
Just to further illustrate this, here are a few more examples:
https://archive.org/details/CoonSongMedleyByRubyBrooks1897-1899
This one is almost just as good as the "Hunky Dory" take. 

https://ia802609.us.archive.org/30/items/CollectedWorksOfRubyBrooks/HappyDaysInDixie1905_64kb.mp3

https://ia802609.us.archive.org/30/items/CollectedWorksOfRubyBrooks/StarsAndStripesForeverMarch1902_64kb.mp3

That's as far as the Brooks transfers go online. There's not that much out there to hear unfortunately, but all that stuff gives us a pretty good picture of his style, and that he lives up to his itinerant roots. Considering Ossman's straight and set ways of banjo playing, he must have found the gift that Brooks had to be lesser, but working with Banta would have granted some respect in Ossman to the self-taught banjoist. If you think about it, Brooks isn't playing too differently from those outstanding unknown banjo player:
http://cylinders.library.ucsb.edu/search.php?queryType=@attr+1=1020&num=1&start=1&query=cylinder12991
I wish there was some way to know who this amazingly folksy and rhythmically perfect banjoist is. Much of how the unknown banjoist plays that tune is similar to how Brooks played it on an Edison record in 1899 or so. 
So in considering all of that, we ought to build up an appreciation for Brooks' records, as before doing some more critical analysis of his records, I didn't find him all that interesting. Before digging in, I assumed that those handful of Climax records Brooks made in 1901 were the best representations of his playing style, but it turns out that was not true at all. These Climax records were questionable in quality, as the only thing you can hear at all is the piano(which is great for studying the pianist, Hylands!), and the banjo is basically not present in the music whatsoever. These records made me believe that Brooks wasn't the best banjoist, and therefore skim through them without interest. After digging into Brooks' story, it seemed more tantalizing and interesting than Ossman's, in terms of stylistic features. Other than all this, the records where this balancing issue was in place were very well made, as those are the examples listed above with Banta piano accompaniment. I wouldn't be able to tell why those Climax records are so out of whack, but every one of them sounds like the way I described. But setting those records aside, Brooks was a great banjoist with quite an interesting style that ought to be studied more often. We often look to Ossman's easy to find and listen to style, but when we step out of the usual Ossman and Van Eps records we find banjoists who were entirely unique, but were unfortunately thrown out of recording rather quick due to Ossman's essential monopoly on banjo records before 1910. There's also Fred Bacon to listen to. Bacon was an absolutely outstanding banjoist, who played very similar to the great Tommy Glynn:
This tintype of Glynn is still floating around out there in the depths of Ebay for nearly $2,000. Hopefully someone can negotiate a reasonable price for this beautiful little thing. 
Glynn was considered the best of these banjoists, and his untimely death at only 25 further created a sort of cult for the former competitors of Glynn's. These former competitors played Glynn's pieces all over, including Ossman, who recorded several of Glynn's pieces for all labels he worked for. This is where we get records like Fred Bacon's 1912 recording of Glynn's "West Lawn Polka". Brooks didn't record any of Glynn's pieces, but it's clear that all those fellow banjoists like Brooks and Ossman very much enjoyed sharing Banta's accompaniments. Considering Banta's status as a popular instrumental accompanist, without much doubt he must have accompanied every one of these famous banjoists, including the obscure Berliner duo Cullen and Collins.


Now then!
I just joined Ancestry and have been stuck learning an overwhelming amount of new information about a variety of recording stars and performers. Before I decide who to pair together in terms of who to write about next, here's a portrait of Victor Emerson's daughter Edna(born 1899) around the early 1920's:
What!
She's absolutely gorgeous! It's curious so see such a beautiful face to come from a notoriously hated man of the Columbia studio. She looks a bit like her uncle Georgie, with those intense and shadowy eyes, and the slightly poked in cheeks of her father and uncle Georgie. 
That's all I'll leave here now before I begin with all the new information in the next posts. 

Hope you enjoyed this! 



Tuesday, February 2, 2016

Mina Hickman before Ada Jones and Some interesting alternate takes

I know nothing of Mina Hickman, but she was a very early female recording artist who needs to be noticed. No one I know has any information on her either, so it's very weird of a case. The only reason I've had a spark of interest in Hickman is because I heard a cylinder yesterday by Len Spencer and Mina Hickman(with Fred Hylands on piano!). I was not at all expecting this duo, I didn't even know that Hickman ever made records with Spencer! That says quite a lot about Spencer's ideas when making records, that he already had  female partner on records before Ada Jones. 

Ada Jones didn't join Spencer on records until 1905, and several years before that, Spencer had Minnie Emmett and Mina Hickman. These two ladies were the "token women" of the Columbia and Victor companies, as this was long before Sophie Tucker and Ada Jones. It was in fact Emmett that Harry Spencer tested his device for recording the female voice in 1897. I don't know any details about this device, but it must have been an interesting contraption. Anyhow, that record of "Reuben and Cynthia" by Spencer and Hickman is here.
(It's the second take listed on the page). It's very weird indeed. Len Spencer, Mina Hickman, and Fred Hylands, on a cylinder in 1901. I wonder where she came from, how and who discovered her, and when exactly. I don't know if it was before 1900, because that's when she began making records. She's a little hard to find any information on, as no matter where you go to find any, you won't find it. Before I began this post, I dug around for anything on Mina, and I couldn't find anything that didn't have to do with listing the records she made. Now, there's something that tells me that Hickman might have been one of those pretty women that Hylands and Spencer endorsed in 1899-1900 on their sheet music covers. She might have been one of those ladies that Hylands or Burt Green had to "bribe" to get her involved with their firm(if you know what I might be getting at...). 

If anyone knows any personal information about Mina Hickman, like where she was born, and when, please comment here!

Now onto the second part of this post. 
This first record is by these two here:
Freddy Hylands 
and Dan Quinn.
Now it's been a while since I have highlighted a record by Quinn, and it's time to do that once again, also to pay my kindly dues to the Quinn family. 
Now this record is one that I don't think I have ever pointed out on here. It's a fun English comic song with great lyrics and fun piano playing. 
Here are two takes of "The Penny Whistler" by Dan Quinn and Fred Hylands, 
recorded in 1903
Now these two takes are very different. Much more than one would think listening to them just once through. The first thing I need to point out about these two takes is that Hylands' rhythm is very unsteady and kind of broken. This is one of those few times where it really sounds like Hylands was drunk on both of the takes. Usually it's one take that's especially noticeable, but both of these are a mess. I do think that take 2 is a little better rhythm wise than take 5. Take 5 is a real mess, and since it was recorded later, it can safely be assumed that Hylands had some drinks between takes. They aren't that far from each other though, it's only a difference of three takes. Three can make a difference. 
Also, here's some observations to make about the differences of these takes;
-Take 5 is slower
-Take 2 has a different 10 second solo by Hylands at the end from take 5

-There's this very slight melodic change that I don't think any of you were able catch, at about 0:15 in on take 2, Hylands hits the same note in the bass between the chords, but listen to that on take 5-- it's a different note!(with a different weird chord also...)

**now that melodic difference ^^ is a very "Hylands" thing, as he did that quite often in his regular playing, which is adding weird notes, octaves, or chords that are not exactly equal with the notes that are being played in the right hand, but do as  matter of fact work when you play them, not exactly when seeing them written**

Now for an even better comparison, here's a different take of it! On a disc this time:
here's the same song but on a Columbia disc,take # not given though :-(
This one also has Hylands on piano, and it's even more interesting and weird from the other takes. This one has some odd aspects to it that were not present on the other ones. You can notice that Hylands' rhythm is even worse on this one than on takes 2 and 5. This one is slower!(at some parts...)The solo at the end is very different from the other two though, and what it is, is very odd, It's kind of a strange little dance section with very rushed trills(as he knew he was running out of time!). 


Onto the second batch of takes. This next one is a bunch of takes of "Bill Bailey" by differing singers and Hylands, all recorded within a few weeks of each other. This song was recorded so many times in 1902 that there's no doubt to be many different takes by the same artists and different ones. Now this first one is a 7-inch of the song with Bob Roberts:
here's take 11.
sounds just as slow as it needs to be, with a perfect tempo chosen by Hylands, paired with fantastic right hand improvisations.
now that you've internalized that take:
here's take 12. 
Quite different indeed. Here are differences:
-Take 12 is slower
-Hylands' rhythm is a little more shaky on take 12
-Hylands was more controlled in playing on take 11
-Hylands hits two chords at 1:26, whereas on take 11, he doesn't do that
- Hylands' left hand is much more steady and controlled on take 11

They are very interesting takes indeed, but there are more! As I said, this song was recorded many times in 1902, so it is easier to find other takes of this one than others. This next take was probably recorded on the same day as the last two, but was released on a cylinder, so it has a much different sound to it. 
Here is another take of Bob Roberts singing "Bill Bailey". 
This is a very fun take as well, even if it's not exactly the same as the other ones. There's quite a lot different about this one. The piano playing is the most Hylands you could get, as every aspect of his playing is present, even the broken octaves(they're hard to hear though...). 
This take is much like Arthur Collins' Zon-O-Phone from the same time, which you can hear here. Now this Zon-O-Phone is one of the most wild examples of Rag-Time I have ever heard on records from the piano accompaniment era. It beats everything Hylands did with Len Spencer in the late-1890's ten fold. It's really an amazing record, with Hylands playing till he dropped on the last strain. One thing is for sure about this Zon-O-Phone, it's not Banta on piano! 

Now this final take is by Collins as well, but it's a Columbia this time, and it's the famous record of "Bill Bailey" that everyone uses. 
Here you go. 
I love that on all of those CD's that had this record on it always say that the pianist is "anonymous" or "unknown", or if they want to seem like they all know what it it they're talking about, it'll say Frank P. Banta. HA! That's all just mush! We all know it's Fred Hylands, and now that he's not forgotten, we can place him rightfully in the section of "Studio pianist" on this record. Seeing the pianist as "unknown" or just "Studio pianist" always irritates me greatly, as they were very hard-working musicians who were almost worked to death for the singers. 

Anyhow, onto a record that's a little bit of a different one. It's a record by a singer I don't mention too often on this blog:
Yes indeed(that's him in c.1900)
Now this cylinder is a bit of a mystery, as the record company cannot be traced. 
here's "My Honolulu Lady" by Frank C. Stanley, c.1898. 
This is a fascinating cylinder, as the record company is unknown, the date is very unsure, and the piano accompaniment is fantastic. Now I have a notion that the piano accompaniment is by Fred Hylands, even if it's an unknown or forgotten record company. The Rag style in the accompaniment is too syncopated and "lazy" if you will for it to be Frank P. Banta. I know that this cylinder cannot be a pirated Edison cylinder, and it is also important to remember that many independent record companies started up in the 1897-1900 era(when this cylinder was recorded), and Frank Stanley did make records for many of these obscure companies in his earliest days of record-making. It's a fantastic cylinder either way, that, even though it's very quiet, it's still very clear, and has the Rag-Time piano mastery of Fred Hylands. 



I hope you enjoyed this! 



Saturday, January 2, 2016

The Lotus Quartet and other items of interest

Happy New Year everyone! Whatever you did to celebrate, I hope it was all right. Now to begin this post, I found this wonderful cylinder from 1902 a few days ago on the Santa Barbara website, and I have fallen in love with it for some reason. It is a cylinder by the Lotus Quartet. I had known not a thing of this group when I found it, but I just yesterday looked in my encyclopedia of early record pseudonyms, and found them listed. 

Before I say the personnel, here is that cylinder.
Why do I like this cylinder so much? Well, it must be how pure and warm the tones of their voices blend together. This group's harmonies touch me more than that of the Greater New York Quartette, or even the mighty Peerless quartet. Here is the personnel, according to my book:
George Seymour Lennox(tenor)
George Stricklett(tenor)
Charles Lewis(baritone)
Frank C. Stanley(bass)

I only know of two of those names. Lennox and Frank Stanley, they were prominent recording stars in the era before 1910, Frank Stanley was all over the place on records, and George Lennox was in many studio quartets here and there. The balance of their voices must have blended somewhat more pleasantly on records than the Invincible Quartet and the Greater New York Quartette. The fact that the singers in the Lotus Quartette were not major recording stars must also make it more pleasant, so when a person who knows the singers' voices listens to it, their voices don't stick out as much. 
Listen to this cylinder here from 1898(with Hylands on piano), this one is by the Greater New York Quartette, and when listening to when they all sing at the chorus, Roger Harding (tenor) sticks out, and also so does Will C. Jones(the bass singer). The problem with Roger Harding was that he couldn't blend in quartets, because of how high and piping his voice was, it was much like the problem with Len Spencer singing in quartets. 
(Harding, 1898)
It was easier to pinpoint him in quartets, not just to modern ears, but also to those who lived back in the days when the records themselves were made. Many who heard the records back in the late-1890's could recognise Harding in a quartet, by that unique tone of his. Same with Len Spencer. It's actually all right that they rid of Len Spencer from the quartet, as the few cylinders with Spencer on them do not sound the best. 

The idea that the record makers(not the management!) had to put Spencer and Harding together was not the best idea either, but it made for some interesting cylinders. 
Here is one of them. Yes, I know I have used this cylinder as an example on this blog before, but it's so odd and interesting in so many ways. Hylands is on piano behind them, and that makes it even more weird! You can hear another one here, recorded on the same day in 1898 or 1899. Those Spencer and Harding with Hylands cylinders were so much fun for them, that they were probably given as gifts for the people who came to Hylands Spencer and Yeager to stay and get music from them(as Harding, Spencer, and Hylands were the main people who ran the firm). After making a bunch of takes of those duets, all three of them must have skipped out early together and went off to Fred's office. 

Now to go a different direction, I would like to speak of the differences between Frank P. Banta and Albert Benzler. 
and 
Albert Benzler.

Why these two? Because they were both pianists for Edison during intertwining terms. Benzler was the pianist from c.1899-1904, and Banta was the pianist from 1896-1903. But before I get into this, there was a third pianist at Edison, Fred Bachman(what's with all the Fred's for pianists? Just a little weird...). I know nothing of Fred Bachman, and I know no one who does. It has occurred to Ryan Wishner and I that all of those cylinders after 1901 with the accompaniment high in the piano notes was all by Benzler. When you hear Banta, that sort of playing was something he never did. When I say that I'm referring to cylinders like these:



There are hundreds more of those cylinders all over the Internet, because Benzler was that pianist who played in the higher register on all of those Edison cylinders. It was not Banta. Banta, on the other hand can be identified on an Edison cylinder from 1899 to 1903 easily, since he was never the one who played in the higher register. His playing sounded very distinct on Edison cylinders, so much different from Benzler. Here is Billy Golden's "Medley of Coon Songs" with Banta form 1903. Just listening to one of the ones above compared with this one really gives you an idea of how different Banta was, you can also hear him here behind Frank Mazziotta in 1902.  Benzler was more of a typical pianist for that time period, as he tried his best to play Rag-Time, but could never really get the feel for it. You can hear Benzler play George Botsford's "Black and White Rag" in 1911. His time is typical of that of a classical pianist, and his playing just barely gets the syncopation correct, still with jolty time. If only Banta lived long enough to record that Rag! 

But of course the best comparison of these two is certainly how they both played Banta's arrangement of "Violets". Here's Banta's from 1903. 
Here's Benzler's from 1905.

They are two very different versions, and Banta's seems more heartfelt and emotional than Benzler's, I guess it's because Benzler had to remake Banta's, and that was all he had to do. Banta just played it as he usually would. One thing that is surprising to me is that the notes on the cylinders both indicate that it was originally recorded on brown wax, but with a different number of course. That is interesting, so that would mean that Banta recorded it originally in 1901, so that indicates that the arrangement of Banta's had been around for a little while by the time he recorded it in 1903. I wonder what it sounded like on brown wax. If there are any copies out there, that's amazing!




I hope you enjoyed this!  


Thursday, October 1, 2015

Organ on cylinders and notions similar

I got a Harmonium this week, and it's the most queer instrument I own currently. It's an amazing portable organ from around 1905, and made by an Indian company, that no longer exists. With this sudden interest in organs, I got into the few cylinders I know of with organ accompaniment behind a singer. These organ accompanied cylinders are always interesting, even if they are usually just sacred songs by Steve Porter.

That's Porter, in c.1897 

Porter had a fondness for recording sacred songs from 1897 to about 1901. This fact is slightly odd, because he did quite a lot of comic songs and minstrel records with the Spencer's. I haven't the least idea why he felt he needed to load up the phonographs with all the sacred songs(rather than splitting the takes with Len Spencer or something). He did share some of the same cylinder numbers with J. W. Myers, which indicates a little bit of splitting up of work. Other than that fact, Porter was know to many phonograph buyers as a singer of the best sacred songs that were sold, and his were always indicated as the best of their kind. 
To begin with these organ accompanied oddities, here is Porter's rendition of "Abide with Me" from 1898, with organ accompaniment by Fred Hylands:
(sorry, it's played too slow, and could sound better on the transfer...)
Now the first thing about Hylands playing the organ is that he wasn't very skilled on the instrument. Hylands probably hadn't had the best experiences with the organ at Columbia, as it must have been a real project to try to get it balanced correctly on the cylinders. Since this was really the first attempt to record the organ commercially(I have heard of Len Spencer trying to record a church organ around 1891-92), it must have been a time for experimentation at Columbia, both on Hylands' part, and all the staff at their studio. 
I can imagine things like the pedals snapping and squeaking with Hylands getting all flustered by this, when they were experimenting with it in 1898. It must have been really something to see, with all of them trying to figure out the thing, and have their Freddy play it to the best he could. 
Since he was a quick-minded anxious piano man, Hylands could more likely than not have been heard playing things like these two Cakewalks here:
Even if reluctantly, Hylands had to play all the frivolous things that J. W. Myers and Steve Porter demanded.
This next one is a cylinder that I have shared on here before, but it's the best example of Hylands' less-than-great organ skills:
Why didn't Myers say anything? I would have turned around after the take and asked about some of this weird things that he played. It's a fascinating cylinder nonetheless, because you can tell that Hylands tries to play some of the things that he was used to playing on the piano, like the trills in the middle of the melodies. I just cannot get over Hylands playing the organ, it's funny and almost great. 
Now to turn to Banta for a moment. 
There's Banta in c.1902.
Now Banta had a much better skill on the organ, and he must have played the instrument more regularly than Hylands did. Here is another rendition of "Abide With Me", but this time by Frank C. Stanley in early 1903.
That's a damn good sounding organ. Edison's organ sounded much more like a pipe organ than Columbia's, I don't know why, but I would love to. One thing that would be great to know is what instrument these recording studios actually used, because there were several kinds of small organs that could have been used, from a small pipe organ to something small like an American version of a Harmonium(which are very small, with only 38 keys).
Here is another Edison example of organ accompaniment by Frank Banta, here you go from 1902. Now this makes the thing sound very interesting, sounding more like Columbia's organ. Here is another one from 1903, with S. H. Dudley.
I have the brown wax Columbia of the cylinder in the link above, so that would mean that Hylands would have to get all the organ parts set up, which must have been something he always dreaded when he came to the studio. Here is the last example I have of Banta's organ skills, and it's one of the most beautiful records I know of from pre-1910. 
I have few records that would fit in this category, but Frank C. Stanley's "The Bellman" from 1902 is certainly one of them, here is that cylinder.
Every time I hear that cylinder I almost get into tears for some reason. It must be Stanley's perfect tone, the powerful chimes, and Banta's organ mastery. (Also because Banta only lived another 13 months after it was recorded...)

Now back to Hylands. This one I have next I have also shared here before for the same reason as the organ accompaniment. This one feature Len Spencer's brother Harry:

(He's the taller guy)
This one is a funny example of Harry and Len Spencer's abilities to capture real-life scenes of the 1890's. That cylinder is here.
It's an interesting cylinder for a lot of reasons, but really try your hardest to focus on the organ playing under Spencer. There's Rag-Time there! Now that way, it's pretty obvious who the organist is( ehm! Hylands). Another thing I just noticed about this cylinder is that other voice toward the beginning, and at the end.  Hmm... Who is that? I know that Len Spencer is also on this cylinder other than Harry, but could one of the three different voices be that of the organist? Freddy Hylands perhaps? He was pretty close to the recording horns on the organ, more so than usual with the piano as you may be able to hear. Here is the other cylinder I think Hylands can be heard on(from the same year):
http://cylinders.library.ucsb.edu/mp3s/9000/9828/cusb-cyl9828d.mp3
It's very possibly Hylands' voice you can hear at the singing toward the end. 
Hear any resemblance? I certainly do, after really taking a few close listens to the two brown wax cylinders. That's really fascinating, as most record collectors would think of those house pianists of this time as silent and solemn workers, but as Hylands worked, he had a loud mouth and wanted to be heard in any way that he could be. These two cylinders above really say true for that notion. Especially the one with Harry Spencer, as now I am convinced that that voice yelling at the end(that's supposed to be a policeman) is probably the voice of Fred Hylands in its clearest form, and at the best volume. The voice also sounds very young, has a slight dialect, and is a trifle scratchy. It's also very different-sounding from anyone I know of at Columbia in 1898. If that's Hylands, he had some voice. 



I hope you enjoyed this!